Forums de discussion pour le document de réflexion

Les trois piliers

Thank you for participating in the Dialogue on Foreign Policy. The interactive web site is now closed. The Minister's report will appear on this web site once it is released.

Ce forum est bilingue, et les participants peuvent rédiger leurs commentaires dans la langue de leur choix.

Sujet précédent | Tous les sujets |

Nouveau sujet | Prochain sujet

Americans are not our "best friends"

Participant: cfallon

Date: 2003-03-13 15:21:38

You can't tell people they get marching orders from Washington because they don't agree with people attacking Americans ("I hate those bastards" was an attack on Americans).

Personally, I feel like Americans are our best friends because I deal with Americans more than any other nations citizens and I feel alot of kinship with the people I interact with.

Our societies share many points of commmonality.

Friends disagree and head in different directions sometimes. But that doesn't dsiqualify there friendship.

I am simple minded however. So, when you tell me that Americans are bullying us over softwood lumber and all, I am not fully convinced that Canada's trading policies are lily-white.

On softwood, I do think we tend to give our forests up to our multinational forest companies for next to nothing and I do think our desire to keep our dollar low (and therefore export friendly) hurts the softwood lumber industry. If our dollar was $1US, there would be no softwood lumber dispute.

But of course, its terrible of me to think that Canada is perhaps less than perfect on these trade issues.

Répondre à ce message

Voir en contexte du sujet

Americans are not our "best friends"

Participant: cougyr

Date: 2003-03-13 23:08:23

Don't confuse individuals with groups. I have relatives, friends and business acquaintances in the US and they are generally likeable people; easy to get along with, as you suggest. When you put individuals into groups, they often behave in ways that they would not when alone. It is the group "Americans" that I have a problem with; not the individuals. That group is presently the most powerful people on earth and acting with terrible immaturity. That group has to learn to join with other countries in order to solve trans national problems. What that group does is act unilaterally; Manifest Destiny; Pax Americana.

Répondre à ce message

Americans are not our "best friends"

Participant: Barretm82

Date: 2003-03-14 23:55:08

So what you are saying is that all your American friends are fine as long as you keep em separated?

If you all get together for lunch, are you saying your American friends are manifesting into gremlins?

If so, you may have bigger problems then you think. :)

Répondre à ce message

Americans are not our "best friends"

Participant: cougyr

Date: 2003-03-16 12:37:55

"If you all get together for lunch, are you saying your American friends are manifesting into gremlins? "
____________________________________

Of course not. However, if we did get together, none of my American friends would ever say, "Let's wage peace along side our Canadian brothers because they are our best friends." or "Let's accept abusive Canadian trade policy because they are our best friends." or "We better not say bad things about Canadians because they are our best friends." They just don't talk like that.

What they will say is, "We are number one and we don't care what Canadians or anyone else thinks about us."

(Read "THE ARROGANCE OF POWER" by US Senator William Fulbright. This was written as a responce to American involvement in Vietnam, but it still applies.)

I understand Americans who stand up for America. What I don't understand is Canadians who don't stand up for Canada when that means disagreeing with Americans.

Répondre à ce message

Americans are not our "best friends"

Participant: fatmomma

Date: 2003-03-16 15:07:23

If your friends say" we are number one and don't care what Canadians or anyone else thinks about us" then you have very arrogant American friends. Many Americans feel the same as Canadians about peace especially in this situation; like most of us, they have listened to reports and come to their own conclusion. Many American companies are adversely affected by the trade wars and do speak up against them. The people are very similar to us; The present American government is not listening to us or its own citizens. Polls vary but most suggest that the American public does not want war without the UN approval.

Répondre à ce message

Americans are not our "best friends"

Participant: Barretm82

Date: 2003-03-16 21:43:28

I have to disagree; I can name many Americans who agree strongly with the Canadian position on 1441. In fact many American people also supported Canada’s offstage proposal at the U.N.

Are there jerks? yes, but every country has them, I suggest that if your Americans friends are jerks, then they really are not your friends.

As far as trade policies, here is an interesting link for you;

http://www.cbc.ca/stories/2003/03/14/freelumber_030314

I applaud the Canadian political fellows who changed tactics and may get a good solution to the lumber problem.

Répondre à ce message

Americans are not our "best friends"

Participant: cougyr

Date: 2003-03-18 14:54:54

" Are there jerks? yes, but every country has them, I suggest that if your Americans friends are jerks, then they really are not your friends. "
________________________________
My friends are not "jerks." Most of them would consider themselves to be patriots; including those who disagree with US policies.

My main concern is that Canadians should stop genuflecting to American policy and set our own course. In this, I truely applaud Chretien's steering Canada out of the Iraq mess. We need more of this independent action.

Répondre à ce message

Sujet précédent | Tous les sujets |

Nouveau sujet | Prochain sujet