DFAIT logo partnership The logo for the by design elab, an independent research development and production think tank specializing in online forums for policy development, incubated in 1997 at the McLuhan Program at the University of Toronto
DFAIT Home Site Map Help Policies Partners Feedback Netcast Français
 
Welcome
Message from the Minister
Dialogue Paper
Answer Questions
View Answers
Discussion Forum
 

Security

Thank you for participating in the Dialogue on Foreign Policy. The interactive web site is now closed. The Minister's report will appear on this web site once it is released.

This Forum is bilingual, and participants post messages in their language of choice.

Should we follow the american lead. Sensible *Americans* wouldn't-- why should we?

Contributor: afrancis

Date: 2003-01-30 20:30:42


Here is a letter written to ex-President Clinton (and actualised so as to send to Pres. Bush) by Robert Bowman who flew 101 combat missions in Vietnam, and is presently bishop of the United Catholic Church in Melbourne Beach, Fla.

http://www.natcath.com/NCR_Online/archives/100298/100298l.htm

Truth is, we’re terrorized because we’re hated
By ROBERT BOWMAN

Tell people the truth, Mr. President -- about terrorism. If deceptions about terrorism go unchallenged, then the threat will continue until it destroys us.

The truth is that none of our thousands of nuclear weapons can protect us from these threats. No Star Wars system -- no matter how technically advanced, no matter how many trillions of dollars are poured into it -- can protect us from a nuclear weapon delivered in a sailboat or a Cessna or a suitcase or a Ryder rental truck. Not one weapon in our vast arsenal, not a penny of the $270 billion a year we spend on so-called defense can defend against a terrorist bomb. That is a military fact.

As a retired lieutenant colonel and a frequent lecturer on national security issues, I have often quoted Psalm 33: “A king is not saved by his mighty army. A warrior is not saved by his great strength.” The obvious reaction is, “Then what can we do? Is there nothing we can do to provide security for our people?”

There is. But to understand it requires that we know the truth about the threat. Mr. President, you did not tell the American people the truth about why we are the targets of terrorism when you explained why we bombed Afghanistan and Sudan. You said that we are a target because we stand for democracy, freedom and human rights in the world. Nonsense!

We are the target of terrorists because, in much of the world, our government stands for dictatorship, bondage and human exploitation. We are the target of terrorists because we are hated. And we are hated because our government has done hateful things.

In how many countries have agents of our government deposed popularly elected leaders and replaced them with puppet military dictators who were willing to sell out their own people to American multinational corporations?

We did it in Iran when the U.S. Marines and the CIA deposed Mossadegh because he wanted to nationalize the oil industry. We replaced him with the Shah and armed, trained and paid his hated Savak national guard, which enslaved and brutalized the people of Iran -- all to protect the financial interests of our oil companies. Is it any wonder that there are people in Iran who hate us?

We did it in Chile. We did it in Vietnam. More recently, we tried to do it in Iraq.

And, of course, how many times have we done it in Nicaragua and all the other banana republics of Latin America? Time after time we have ousted popular leaders who wanted the riches of the land to be shared by the people who worked it. We replaced them with murderous tyrants who would sell out their own people so the wealth of the land could be taken out by the likes of Domino Sugar, the United Fruit Company, Folgers and Chiquita Banana.

In country after country, our government has thwarted democracy, stifled freedom and trampled human rights. That’s why it is hated around the world. And that’s why we’re the target of terrorists.

People in Canada enjoy democracy, freedom and human rights. So do the people of Norway and Sweden. Have you heard of Canadian embassies being bombed? Or Norwegian, or Swedish?

We are not hated because we practice democracy, freedom and human rights. We are hated because our government denies these things to people in Third World countries whose resources are coveted by our multinational corporations. That hatred we have sown has come back to haunt us in the form of terrorism -- and in the future, nuclear terrorism.

Once the truth about why the threat exists is understood, the solution becomes obvious. We must change our ways. Getting rid of our nuclear weapons -- unilaterally if necessary -- will enhance our security. Drastically altering our foreign policy will ensure it.

Instead of sending our sons and daughters around the world to kill Arabs so we can have the oil under their sand, we should send them to rebuild their infrastructure, supply clean water and feed starving children. Instead of continuing to kill thousands of Iraqi children every day with our sanctions, we should help Iraqis rebuild their electric power plants, their water treatment facilities, their hospitals -- all the things we destroyed and prevented them from rebuilding with sanctions.

Instead of training terrorists and death squads, we should close the School of the Americas. Instead of supporting insurrection, destabilization, assassination and terror around the world, we should abolish the CIA and give the money to relief agencies.

In short, we should do good instead of evil. Who would try to stop us? Who would hate us? Who would want to bomb us?

That is the truth, Mr. President. That’s what the American people need to hear.

Robert Bowman flew 101 combat missions in Vietnam. He is presently bishop of the United Catholic Church in Melbourne Beach, Fla.

National Catholic Reporter, October 2, 1998

Reply to this message

Should we follow the american lead. Sensible *Americans* wouldn't-- why should we?

Contributor: marl

Date: 2003-01-31 12:00:18


Congratulations for finding this article. It's too bad the mainstream press doesn't publish more articles like this. Most Americans still believe the outright lies that are told to them. The present struggle in Venezuela and the tragedies taking place in Argentina are two examples where totally biased misinformation is fed to the public. Unfortunately, there are also a great many Canadians who are willing to believe whatever is fed to them on the nightly "news". With an issue such as Canada's possible involvement in an attack against Iraq on the agenda in the House of Commons, I had hoped that more people would become involved in this debate. It is very sad that so few have. There is a world wide 5 minute "Prayer for Peace" being planned for Feb. 14 at 12:00 noon New York time. Perhaps those people who have not had the time or energy to get involved in active debate will spend 5 minutes on that day to contemplate the need for peace on this planet.

Reply to this message

Should we follow the american lead. Sensible *Americans* wouldn't-- why should we?

Contributor: diana

Date: 2003-02-17 15:28:31


I just want to say that is the most clearly articulated and, in my opinion, accurate statement I have read about terrorism against the US and about the situation in Iraq. With the US "why us" mentality so entrenched, and the American media so fervently advocating war, I wonder how that kind of thinking can be turned around, so that Americans see their culpability and pressure their government to create more humanitarian foreign policies. The world wide peace rallies made me feel very hopeful. Perhaps they will make the ordinary American think twice about the accepted line of reasoning.

Reply to this message

Should we follow the american lead. Sensible *Americans* wouldn't-- why should we?

Contributor: YvonLattrapé

Date: 2003-02-18 22:50:39


I think that YES, we should follow the American lead. I love the USA, but especially the amazing President George W. Bush. He is a genious, and also a man who is a living example of generosity, kindness, social justice. He is the greatest President of the United States history. That's why Canada should follow his wise opinion then destroy Irak, no matter if collateral damages occur. That's the cost of Liberty, and we shall be ready to pay for it.

God Bless America. God Bless the Great George W. Bush.

Reply to this message